“We were married, we were married, and that was part of his support” [Caitlyn] like her father,” Taylor said. Despite his protests against any legal responsibility towards the girl, Sydney had a close relationship with Caitlyn, according to Judge Manuel. “Although he [Sydney] was never appointed as legal guardian, he acted as her guardian and would have been her guardian as Miss [Taylor] died,” Judge Manuel said. Judge Manuel said in her decision that Sydney’s support for Caitlyn was significant and met all of the girl’s needs during those six years. Sydney said he was only providing support for the sake of his marriage, but Judge Manuel disagreed.